Posts

The Refutation of Materialism

Image
The Refutation of Materialism written by Felipe Bautista Under no circumstances whatsoever is it difficult or challenging to refute materialism, principally because materialism entails a contradiction in terms: namely, materialism entails transcendental realism, the belief in the continued existence of objects after they no longer appear to the senses ( cf. Kant’s Critique of the Fourth Paralogism). In his Treatise of Human Nature , Hume wrote that “To begin with the senses, ’tis evident these faculties are incapable of giving rise to the notion of the continu’d existence of their objects, after they no longer appear to the senses. For that is a contradiction in terms, and supposes that the senses continue to operate, even after they have ceas’d all manner of operation”; and, in his first Enquiry , he emphasized that “It is a question of fact, whether the perceptions of the senses be produced by external objects, resembling them: How shall this question be determined? By experience su...